Two students are arguing over whether or not air is matter. They both argue different claims.
Student 1's claim: "Air is not matter because we cannot feel it or touch it like we can solids and liquids. It is too small and invisible. We have to be able to see matter and interact with it."
Student 2's claim: "Air is matter. We know this because it is a gas and has mass and volume. Being able to see it isn't a defining feature of matter."
Which claim do you agree with?