Who's work are you reviewing?

Who is sharing their project first?

You can see your partner's Project Proposal -- the screen has been shared

Are the aesthetics well considered?

Will the kinetic artwork be visually interesting.

Why or Why not?

Give at least 1 compliment about the aesthetics

What is something you like about the "look" of the project?

Give at least 1 suggestion for the aesthetics

How can the "look" be improved?

Will the mechanisms work?

Will the desired movement be achieved?

Why or Why not?

Give at least 1 compliment about the mechanics

What is something you like about the movements & how the mechanics make it move?

Give at least 1 suggestion for the mechanics

How can the "function" be improved? What will make it work better?

Answer all parts of this question:

What is one thing that you will take away from this "peer review" experience?

Did you get a good piece of advice about your aethetics? your mechanics?

Will you change any part of your design now after this review?

Why or Why not?