Log in
Sign up for FREE
arrow_back
Library

ELA 09.06.24 - CER Response Questions

star
star
star
star
star
Last updated about 2 hours ago
16 questions
9
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
DO NOW Directions: Look at the text for The Other Side of the Sky from the assignment ELA 09.04.24 - The Other Side of the Sky or at the bottom of this page. Then, list each of the events from the story below as 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 4th in the order of events as they appear in the story.
All Claims, Evidence, and Reasoning will be graded on the this rubric:
**CER Response Rubric** Claim (3 pt) *The Claim answers the question.(1pt) *The Claim uses important words from the question (including the subject). (1pt) *The Claim is a complete sentence (with a capital letter at the beginning and a period at the end). (1pt) Evidence (3pt) *There is a Lead-in that introduces the quote (usually by saying, The author writes,) (1pt) *The Evidence is a word-for-word quote from the text (with "quotation marks" around it) (1pt) *There is an Author's Citation which contains the last name of the author (in (Parenthesis)) (1pt) Reasoning (3pt) *Reasoning explains how or why the evidence above it supports the claim.
All Claims, Evidence, and Reasoning will be graded on the this rubric:
**CER Response Rubric** Claim (3 pt)
  • *The Claim answers the question.(1pt)
  • *The Claim uses important words from the question (including the subject). (1pt)
  • *The Claim is a complete sentence (with a capital letter at the beginning and a period at the end). (1pt)
Evidence (3pt)
  • *There is a Lead-in that introduces the quote (usually by saying, The author writes,) (1pt)
  • *The Evidence is a word-for-word quote from the text (with "quotation marks" around it) (1pt)
  • *There is an Author's Citation which contains the last name of the author (in (Parenthesis)) (1pt)
Reasoning (3pt)
  • *Reasoning explains how or why the evidence above it supports the claim.
Question 1
1.

CER Responses
Why couldn't Ahmedi and her mother get any nearer to the gate to the Pakistani border? Cite specific evidence from paragraphs 1 and 2 of the text to support your answer.

In the same answer box:
  1. Write a claim to answer each question
  2. Write evidence that supports the claim
  3. Write reasoning the explains why your evidence supports your claim
Use the CER Response Rubrics above when crafting your responses.

Question 2
2.

On the second day Ahmedi learned a few people were being allowed to enter Pakistan. Why didn’t this knowledge help her and her mother? Cite specific evidence from paragraphs 5-9 to support your response.
In the same answer box:
  • Write a claim to answer each question
  • Write evidence that supports the claim
  • Write reasoning the explains why your evidence supports your claim
Use the CER Response Rubrics above when crafting your responses.

Question 3
3.

Question #3
What physical challenges did Ahmedi and her mother face as they crossed the mountain? Support your answers with specific evidence from paragraphs 11 and 12 of the text. In the same answer box: Write a claim to answer each question Write evidence that supports the claim Write reasoning the explains why your evidence supports your claim Use the CER Response Rubrics above when crafting your responses.

Question 4
4.

Question #4
What are examples of survival or people trying to survive in the text of The Other Side of the Sky? In the same answer box: Write a claim to answer each question Write evidence that supports the claim Write reasoning the explains why your evidence supports your claim Use the CER Response Rubrics above when crafting your responses.

1
0
1
1
1
Question 9
9.
Question 10
10.


Question 11
11.

Other Answer Choices:
Question 12
12.
Question 13
13.
_______ dfghfgdhfg_______ fghfghfgh
Question 14
14.
Question 15
15.

What are examples of survival or people trying to survive in the text of The Other Side of the Sky?

survival people survive
Question 16
16.

The Other Side of the Sky by Farah Ahmedi
From: Escape from Afghanistan
  1. The gate to Pakistan was closed, and I could see that the Pakistani border guards were letting no one through. People were pushing and shoving and jostling up against that gate, and the guards were driving them back. As we got closer, the crowd thickened, and I could hear the roar and clamor at the gate. The Afghans were yelling something, and the Pakistanis were yelling back. My mother was clutching her side and gasping for breath, trying to keep up. I felt desperate to get through, because the sun was setting, and if we got stuck here, what were we going to do? Where would we stay? There was nothing here, no town, no hotel, no buildings, just the desert.
  2. Yet we had no real chance of getting through. Big strong men were running up to the gate in vain. The guards had clubs, and they had carbines, too, which they turned around and used as weapons. Again and again, the crowd surged toward the gate and the guards drove them back with their sticks and clubs, swinging and beating until the crowd receded. And after that, for the next few minutes, on our side of the border, people milled about and muttered and stoked their own impatience and worked up their rage, until gradually the crowd gathered strength and surged against that gate again, only to be swept back.
  3. We never even got close to the front. We got caught up in the thinning rear end of the crowd, and even so, we were part of each wave, pulled forward, driven back. It was hard for me to keep my footing, and my mother was clutching my arm now, just hanging on, just trying to stay close to me, because the worst thing would have been if we had gotten separated. Finally, I saw that it was no use. We were only risking injury. We drifted back, out of the crowd. In the thickening dusk we could hear the dull roar of people still trying to get past the border guards, but we receded into the desert, farther and farther back from the border gate.
  4. Night was falling, and we were stranded out there in the open. …
  5. On that second day, however, I learned that it was all a question of money. Someone told me about this, and then I watched closely and saw that it was true. Throughout the day, while some of the guards confronted the crowds, a few others lounged over to the side. People approached them quietly. Money changed hands, and the guards then let those people quietly through a small door to the side.
  6. Hundreds could have flowed through the main gate had it been opened, but only one or two could get through the side door at a time. The fact that the guards were taking bribes did us no good whatsoever. We did not have the money to pay them. What little we had we would need to get from Peshawar to Quetta. And so the second day passed.
  7. At the end of that day we found ourselves camping near a friendly family. We struck up a conversation with them. The woman told us that her husband, Ghulam Ali, had gone to look for another way across the border. He was checking out a goat path that supposedly went over the mountains several miles northeast of the border station. If one could get to Pakistan safely by that route, he would come back for his family. “You can go with us,” the woman said.
  8. Later that night her husband showed up. “It works,” he said. “Smugglers use that path, and they bribe the guards to leave it unguarded. Of course, we don’t want to run into any smugglers, either, but if we go late at night, we should be fine.”
  9. His wife then told him our story, and Ghulam Ali took pity on us. “Yes, of course you can come with us,” he said. “But you have had two hard days. You will need some rest before you attempt this mountain crossing. Spend tonight here and sleep well, knowing that you will have nothing to do tomorrow except lounge around, rest, and catch your breath. Tomorrow, do not throw yourself against those border guards again. Let your only work be the gathering of your strength. Then tomorrow night we will all go over the mountain together, with God’s grace. I will show you the way. If God wills it, we will follow that smugglers’ path to safety. You and your mother are in my care now.”
  10. So we spent the whole next day there. It was terribly warm and we had no water, but we walked a little way and found a mosque that refugees like us had built over the years, so that people waiting to get across the border would have a place to say their prayers. We got some water to drink at the mosque, and we said namaz there too. Somehow we obtained a little bit of bread as well. I can’t remember how that turned up, but there it was, and we ate it. We sustained our strength. After sunset we lay down just as if were going to spend another night. In fact, I did fall asleep for a while. Long after dark—or early the next morning, to be exact, before the sun came up—that man shook us awake. “It’s time,” he said.
  11. We got up and performed our ablutions quickly in the darkness, with just sand because that’s allowed when you have no access to water. We said our prayers. Then Ghulam Ali began to march into the darkness with his family, and we trudged along silently behind them. After several miles the path began to climb, and my mother began to wheeze. Her asthma was pretty bad at this point, poor thing. No doubt, her anxiety made it worse, but in such circumstances how could she rid herself of anxiety? It was no use knowing that her difficulty was rooted in anxiety, just as it was no use knowing that we could have moved more quickly if we had possessed wings. Life is what it is. The path over that mountain was not actually very long, only a couple of miles. Steep as it was, we could have gotten over in little more than an hour if not for my mother. Because of her, we had to pause every few minutes, so our journey took many hours.
  12. I myself hardly felt the exertion. I was walking quite well that day, quite athletically. I had that good prosthetic leg from Germany. The foot was a little worn by then, but not enough to slow me down. Thinking back, I’m puzzled, actually. How did I scale that mountain so easily? How did I climb down the other side? These days I find it hard to clamber up two or three flights of stairs, even. I don’t know what made me so supple and strong that day, but I felt no hardship, no anxiety or fear, just concentration and intensity. Perhaps my mother’s problems distracted me from my own. That might account for it. Perhaps desperation gave me energy and made me forget the rigor of the climb. Well, whatever the reason, I scrambled up like a goat. The family we were following had a girl only a bit younger than me, and she was moving slowly. Her family used my example to chide her. They kept saying, “Look at that girl. She’s missing a leg, and yet she’s going faster than you. Why can’t you keep up? Hurry now!”
  13. That Ghulam Ali was certainly a good man, so patient with us and so compassionate. He had never seen us before, and yet when he met us, he said, “I will help you.” That’s the thing about life. You never know when and where you will encounter a spot of human decency. I have felt alone in this world at times; I have known long periods of being no one. But then, without warning, a person like Ghulam Ali just turns up and says, “I see you. I am on your side.” Strangers have been kind to me when it mattered most. That sustains a person’s hope and faith. Excerpted from The Other Side of the Sky by Farah Ahmedi, published by Simon & Schuster
The Other Side of the Sky by Farah Ahmedi
From: Escape from Afghanistan
  1. The gate to Pakistan was closed, and I could see that the Pakistani border guards were letting no one through. People were pushing and shoving and jostling up against that gate, and the guards were driving them back. As we got closer, the crowd thickened, and I could hear the roar and clamor at the gate. The Afghans were yelling something, and the Pakistanis were yelling back. My mother was clutching her side and gasping for breath, trying to keep up. I felt desperate to get through, because the sun was setting, and if we got stuck here, what were we going to do? Where would we stay? There was nothing here, no town, no hotel, no buildings, just the desert.
  2. Yet we had no real chance of getting through. Big strong men were running up to the gate in vain. The guards had clubs, and they had carbines, too, which they turned around and used as weapons. Again and again, the crowd surged toward the gate and the guards drove them back with their sticks and clubs, swinging and beating until the crowd receded. And after that, for the next few minutes, on our side of the border, people milled about and muttered and stoked their own impatience and worked up their rage, until gradually the crowd gathered strength and surged against that gate again, only to be swept back.
  3. We never even got close to the front. We got caught up in the thinning rear end of the crowd, and even so, we were part of each wave, pulled forward, driven back. It was hard for me to keep my footing, and my mother was clutching my arm now, just hanging on, just trying to stay close to me, because the worst thing would have been if we had gotten separated. Finally, I saw that it was no use. We were only risking injury. We drifted back, out of the crowd. In the thickening dusk we could hear the dull roar of people still trying to get past the border guards, but we receded into the desert, farther and farther back from the border gate.
  4. Night was falling, and we were stranded out there in the open. …
  5. On that second day, however, I learned that it was all a question of money. Someone told me about this, and then I watched closely and saw that it was true. Throughout the day, while some of the guards confronted the crowds, a few others lounged over to the side. People approached them quietly. Money changed hands, and the guards then let those people quietly through a small door to the side.
  6. Hundreds could have flowed through the main gate had it been opened, but only one or two could get through the side door at a time. The fact that the guards were taking bribes did us no good whatsoever. We did not have the money to pay them. What little we had we would need to get from Peshawar to Quetta. And so the second day passed.
  7. At the end of that day we found ourselves camping near a friendly family. We struck up a conversation with them. The woman told us that her husband, Ghulam Ali, had gone to look for another way across the border. He was checking out a goat path that supposedly went over the mountains several miles northeast of the border station. If one could get to Pakistan safely by that route, he would come back for his family. “You can go with us,” the woman said.
  8. Later that night her husband showed up. “It works,” he said. “Smugglers use that path, and they bribe the guards to leave it unguarded. Of course, we don’t want to run into any smugglers, either, but if we go late at night, we should be fine.”
  9. His wife then told him our story, and Ghulam Ali took pity on us. “Yes, of course you can come with us,” he said. “But you have had two hard days. You will need some rest before you attempt this mountain crossing. Spend tonight here and sleep well, knowing that you will have nothing to do tomorrow except lounge around, rest, and catch your breath. Tomorrow, do not throw yourself against those border guards again. Let your only work be the gathering of your strength. Then tomorrow night we will all go over the mountain together, with God’s grace. I will show you the way. If God wills it, we will follow that smugglers’ path to safety. You and your mother are in my care now.”
  10. So we spent the whole next day there. It was terribly warm and we had no water, but we walked a little way and found a mosque that refugees like us had built over the years, so that people waiting to get across the border would have a place to say their prayers. We got some water to drink at the mosque, and we said namaz there too. Somehow we obtained a little bit of bread as well. I can’t remember how that turned up, but there it was, and we ate it. We sustained our strength. After sunset we lay down just as if were going to spend another night. In fact, I did fall asleep for a while. Long after dark—or early the next morning, to be exact, before the sun came up—that man shook us awake. “It’s time,” he said.
  11. We got up and performed our ablutions quickly in the darkness, with just sand because that’s allowed when you have no access to water. We said our prayers. Then Ghulam Ali began to march into the darkness with his family, and we trudged along silently behind them. After several miles the path began to climb, and my mother began to wheeze. Her asthma was pretty bad at this point, poor thing. No doubt, her anxiety made it worse, but in such circumstances how could she rid herself of anxiety? It was no use knowing that her difficulty was rooted in anxiety, just as it was no use knowing that we could have moved more quickly if we had possessed wings. Life is what it is. The path over that mountain was not actually very long, only a couple of miles. Steep as it was, we could have gotten over in little more than an hour if not for my mother. Because of her, we had to pause every few minutes, so our journey took many hours.
  12. I myself hardly felt the exertion. I was walking quite well that day, quite athletically. I had that good prosthetic leg from Germany. The foot was a little worn by then, but not enough to slow me down. Thinking back, I’m puzzled, actually. How did I scale that mountain so easily? How did I climb down the other side? These days I find it hard to clamber up two or three flights of stairs, even. I don’t know what made me so supple and strong that day, but I felt no hardship, no anxiety or fear, just concentration and intensity. Perhaps my mother’s problems distracted me from my own. That might account for it. Perhaps desperation gave me energy and made me forget the rigor of the climb. Well, whatever the reason, I scrambled up like a goat. The family we were following had a girl only a bit younger than me, and she was moving slowly. Her family used my example to chide her. They kept saying, “Look at that girl. She’s missing a leg, and yet she’s going faster than you. Why can’t you keep up? Hurry now!”
  13. That Ghulam Ali was certainly a good man, so patient with us and so compassionate. He had never seen us before, and yet when he met us, he said, “I will help you.” That’s the thing about life. You never know when and where you will encounter a spot of human decency. I have felt alone in this world at times; I have known long periods of being no one. But then, without warning, a person like Ghulam Ali just turns up and says, “I see you. I am on your side.” Strangers have been kind to me when it mattered most. That sustains a person’s hope and faith. Excerpted from The Other Side of the Sky by Farah Ahmedi, published by Simon & Schuster
Question 5
5.

Question #1

Why couldn't Ahmedi and her mother get any nearer to the gate to the Pakistani border? Cite specific evidence from paragraphs 1 and 2 of the text to support your answer.

In the same answer box:
  1. Write a claim to answer each question
  2. Write evidence that supports the claim
  3. Write reasoning the explains why your evidence supports your claim
Use the CER Response Rubrics above when crafting your responses.

Question 6
6.

Question 7
7.

On the second day Ahmedi learned a few people were being allowed to enter Pakistan. Why didn’t this knowledge help her and her mother? Cite specific evidence from paragraphs 5-9 to support your response.
In the same answer box:
  • Write a claim to answer each question
  • Write evidence that supports the claim
  • Write reasoning the explains why your evidence supports your claim
Use the CER Response Rubrics above when crafting your responses.

Question 8
8.

What physical challenges did Ahmedi and her mother face as they crossed the mountain? Support your answers with specific evidence from paragraphs 11 and 12 of the text. In the same answer box: Write a claim to answer each question Write evidence that supports the claim Write reasoning the explains why your evidence supports your claim Use the CER Response Rubrics above when crafting your responses.

DO NOW

Order these events chronologically as they appear in the story The Other Side of the Sky.
The text is below if you need it.
In spite of her prosthetic leg, the narrator went up and down the mountain like a sure-footed goat.
The Pakistani border guards kept shoving the Afghani refugees away from the gate while both groups were yelling back and forth at each other.
Ghulam Ali checked out a goat path that smugglers often use.
After they started to climb the mountain, the narrator’s mother began to suffer an asthma attack.